Question for the Group

1 min read

Deviation Actions

Talk-Philosophy's avatar
Published:
1.1K Views
Are humans good or evil? Why/why not?
© 2010 - 2024 Talk-Philosophy
Comments11
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
Day5pr1ng's avatar
"Are humans good or evil? Why/why not?"

My conclusion is that humans are evil (which is not to say that they are incapable of involvement in good) and my reasoning is as follows...

First, we dispose of the concept of relative morality (which is self-refuting) and turn to an objective moral authority.
Proposition 1: A relative conception of morality (including evil) which comes from mankind is self-refuting.
Proposition 2: Nature cannot generate or provide a conception of morality.
Proposition 3: An objective morality (including evil) cannot come from a person or group of persons.
Conclusion 1: For a rational moral philosophy one must turn to the maker of mankind and nature, God. (I would argue from here specifically for the Christian God.)

Then we learn our connection to that moral authority, His views, and our history with Him.
Premise 1: Mankind was made perfect, by a perfect being.
Premise 2: Mankind was to live with gratitude, humility, and obedience to one law; "Do not eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil".
Premise 3: Man turned on his maker, disobeyed, and was corrupted by that decision against the very perfection of God.
Conclusion 2: Having turned against our perfect maker, we have been corrupted and now pass it on to each generation.

Lastly, we put it together for a final conclusion to the question.
Premise c1: For a rational moral philosophy one must turn to God. (I would argue from here specifically for the Christian God.)
Premise c2: Having turned against our perfect maker, we have been corrupted and now pass that corruption on to each generation.
Conclusion 3: Mankind is aware of and even desires evil, which is well defined as those things which are opposing God's nature and decrees.

Not the happiest of conclusions, but that isn't the goal.

Grace and peace,
Day


Romans 7:24-25
What a wretched man I am! Who will rescue me from this body that is subject to death? Thanks be to God, who delivers me through Jesus Christ our Lord!